Gut Instinct? Mine says no…

I was browsing through my phone media, pondering a blog today on fatigue, and then this article popped up in front of my eyes.

image

Link is at the bottom of the page.

To those not familiar with the RA or indeed the autoimmune world this is one of those areas that immediately provokes lively conversation, and often dissenting views. It’s a marmite issue if you will 🙂

Leaky gut is a term that’s been floating around for years, often touted by people who think gluten is evil, we should refuse all meds, and we should probably all live on organic mung beans. Served in knitted yoghurt pots. It’s a nonsense term as of course the gut ‘leaks’, it’s designed to. How else would we absorb goodness/drugs etc into our bodies?!

I’m being slightly flippant here but you can probably guess which side of the fence I fall on. My rheumatologist tells me diet is irrelevant. My personal experience tells me so. My GP agrees – standard advice is that a healthy balanced diet is best, do not exclude food groups unless you have a medically diagnosed allergy, as it causes more harm than good.

There is no scientific evidence to prove diet affects RA in any way.  Yet. I do keep an open mind. Honestly! However….

I’m still very dubious. I just don’t believe the answer is this simple. Bearing in mind this research has been targeted to ‘prove’ a theory already held by the researchers (and of course this is common practice), it is still full of its, coulds, shoulds, mights and maybes.

So is it possible those of us with RA have gut problems? Absolutely,  it’s actually incredibly common.  But my logical head tells me there has to be more to it, it’s not as simple as “which came first RA or Bacteria”?!

But this research comes nowhere near to explaining the following –

Why some families have clusters of Autoimmune conditions whilst others have sole sufferers?

Why some suffer from JIA almost from the birth and others don’t show symptoms until they are 40-50 yrs old?

It doesn’t explain the huge prevalence of woman over men with autoimmune.

It doesn’t explain why some patients with autoimmune commonly have more than one condition diagnosed.

It doesn’t explain why some patients who eat “clean” diets still suffer symptoms.

And some don’t.

I absolutely believe the “gut”, gallbladder, liver, pancreas etc may well be involved. We have a complicated system that relies on food of many different types to stay balanced and healthy. I along with millions of others suffer IBS alongside RD, but so do many without it.

In my own humble and very non scientific mind I strongly believe RA, along with many other conditions is genetic in origin. It might well be triggered at any point in our lifetimes by stress or bacteria or illness or injury or pregnancy, but if that genetic marker for RA isn’t there it can’t and won’t occur.

I will, with many others, watch this space, small discoveries like this often lead to other bigger things,  and as I’ve said before I may be opinionated but I’m not closed minded ☺ I actually hope for all our sakes this leads RA research forwards.

http://individualizedmedicineblog.mayoclinic.org/discussion/microbiome-biomarker-found-that-triggers-rheumatoid-arthritis/?utm_content=bufferd6eea&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “Gut Instinct? Mine says no…

  1. Totally agree with your take on things Denise. Wonder diets and food fads are not for me..I still have a life to lead and enjoy. RD is an ass, and a complicated ass at that. We may have subtle ideas of why it happened, what triggered it etc but we don’t know for sure. For every 10 people saying it’s genetic there are 10 saying it’s not. One things for sure though..if you have RD or any other autoimmune condition (I have 3) then you need a good medical team taking care of you.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I agree 100% but if I eat a lot of candy I flare. Am I alergic? I don’t know I’ve never been tested. But I do. Some do flare with certain foods and they flare but I believe that it’s alergies and when we put stress on our systems (or ourselves for that matter) we flare. Wonderful blog.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for your kind comment! I know others who say sugar causes flares for them too. The only direct ‘food’ impact I’ve seen is red wine, I drink very rarely because of meds but noticed

      Like

      1. Jerry in clicked reply too early! I was trying to say that on two occasions one glass of red wine almost immediately raised swelling in my hands and redness across my Knuckles. It’s certainly a fascinating area for all of us today keep an eye on!

        Like

  3. I have always believed that I am genetically predisposed to certain autoimmune disease. However, I think something triggers the reaction but who knows for certain what.

    pssst…..(RABlog Week will be back in September)

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I love your Blog I listen to my medical team they are first and foremost number one for me when it comes to treating my Autoimmune conditions I’ve had scopes done on my gut and everything is great there 👍in saying that we are all unique and everyone’s bodies react differently. I was also like u was told the same about food and Gluten that u only need to stop if u have an intolerance to it and they said I don’t have any intolerances to either gluten or dairy. Anyway great blog
    Judy

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s